BMJ takes two months to publish letter on Lightning Process and SMILE pilot study in children
December 21, 2010
A not very rapid Response: BMJ takes two months to publish letter on Lightning Process and SMILE pilot study in children
On 14 July, I submitted a Rapid Response to the BMJ in reply to a response published on 8 March by a Dr Munglani, Consultant in Pain Medicine, West Suffolk Hospital. Dr Munglani had recommended the Lightning Process and given a link to the Lightning Process website in the references at the end of his own Rapid Response to an article about pain management, published in the BMJ in January.
BMJ Rapid Responses usually appear within two or three days following submission and when mine failed to appear on the site, I assumed it had been rejected for publication by the Rapid Response Letters Editor.
In fact, my letter was published by the BMJ but not until 14 September. Why this letter had been held back over two months isn’t known and an enquiry to the Letters Editor has met with no response.
My Rapid Response can be read here on the BMJ site:
BMJ Original article:
Views & Reviews: From the Frontline: Bad medicine: pain
Des Spence (Published 6 January 2010)
Rapid Response Re: Failure to appreciate pain is a symptom not a diagnosis is what leads to bad medicine
Suzy Chapman, BMJ (Published 14 September 2010):
in reply to Rapid Response to article: “From the Frontline: Bad medicine: pain”:
Failure to appreciate pain is a symptom not a diagnosis is what leads to bad medicine, Rajesh Munglani, BMJ (Published 8 March 2010):
Between late July and early August, the testimonials by Dr Munglani to which I had referred in my response were taken down from the website of the Rowan Centre. Dr Munglani’s testimonials had read:
“I have been very impressed with the results of the LP. I have seen the lives of some of my patients transformed by this self empowering technique. Everyone who has battled with chronic illness and wants to win should have an opportunity to do the Lightning Process. Professor Rajesh Munglani. MB BS DCH DA FRCA FFPMRCA. Consultant in pain medicine. West Suffolk Hospital and Nuffield Health Cambridge Hospital.”
Between late July and early August, the Rowan Centre ceased offering the Lightning Process and all references to the Lightning Process and Lightning Process logos have been removed from their webpage. They now offer their own flavour of the “process”, known as the “BodyMind Programme”.
See their rationale for distancing themselves from the Lightning Process here:
Text on the Rowan Centre website was changed from:
“People using the Lightning ProcessTM have recovered from, or experienced significant improvement with the following issues and conditions…”
“We have helped people with the following illnesses and conditions…”
Text on their “Introduction” page reads:
“There are now NHS and private consultants, GPs and occupational therapists referring their patients to us at the Rowan Centre. Clinicians in the NHS have observed the work we do. To find out more, you can speak to Gael Postle, Occupational Therapist at the James Paget University Hospital pain clinic on 01493 453307 or the O.T.s at the Norfolk and Suffolk ME/CFS service on 01502 527579.”
The Rowan Centre also offer their programme for MS patients.
Another Lightning Process site which has changed its text since late July is this one:
which has changed:
“What does it work for?
People using the Lightning Process® have also recovered from, or experienced significant improvement with the following conditions:-
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
Post Viral Fatigue
Anxiety And Panic Attacks
Low Self Esteem
Motor Neurone Disease
Hyper And Hypo Thyroidism
Chronic Aches And Pains
Type 2 Diabetes
Noise And Light Sensitivity
And Many More
Using the Lightning Process® has proven effective for clearing ALL the debilitating physical and mind based symptoms of ME, chronic fatigue syndrome, and post viral syndrome.
Some of the symptoms that people have cleared are listed here…”
[long list of conditions]
to “What do we work with?”
[shorter list of conditions]
Here’s a site that hasn’t changed its text:
A Manchester and Cumbria practitioner
“The Phil Parker Lightning ProcessTM is a hugely successful training programme which has transformed the lives of thousands of people whose problems had previously seemed impossible to resolve such as Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME), Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS), Post-Viral Fatigue Syndrome (PVFS), Fibromyalgia, Multiple Sclerosis (MS), Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD), Anxiety, Depression and many other debilitating issues.
Helen James is a fully qualified Lightning Process Advanced Practitioner, with many years experience in helping people to recover from numerous conditions. For more information about Helen see the About Helen page.
Many people that have already used the Lightning Process to recover from the above conditions had previously tried all sorts of alternative healthcare treatments and complementary therapies, but the only treatment that is consistently helping 1500 suffers a year to recover is the Lightning Process. 85% of people that have the attended a Lightning Process training make a full recovery, and the recovery is permanent.
Further applications for the Lightning Process
The Lightning Process can help you to recover from/resolve any of the following…
.Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME)
.Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS)
.Post-Viral Fatigue Syndrome (PVFS)
.Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)
.Allergies including Hay Fever
.Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS)
.Hyper and Hypo Thyroidism
.Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
.Anxiety and Panic Attacks
.Focal Dystonia (undesirable muscular contraction or twisting)
.Low self esteem
.Lyme Disease also known as Borrelia or Borreliosis.
.Noise and Light Sensitivity
.Chronic Aches and Pains
And it’s also effective for enhancing:
.Peak Sports Performance
Multiple Sclerosis (MS)
Over the last few years we have started to see number of people getting impressive results when using the Lightning Process with other neurological conditions such as CFS, Parkinsonian type tremors, cerebral palsy and strokes. As a consequence we were asked whether the Lightning Process could be used for improvement and recovery with any other types of neurological illness, particularly Multiple Sclerosis…”
Landmark agreement extends ASA’s digital remit
In March 2011, the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) broadens its remit to include website content:
1] SMILE – Specialist Medical Intervention and Lightning Evaluation documents (Lightning Process pilot study – children [now aged 12 to 18] with CFS and ME): http://wp.me/p5foE-37x
2] Background to this issue: http://wp.me/p5foE-2Vt
3] All posts on Lightning Process pilot study in children issue:
4] Minutes, meeting of the SMILE Pilot External Advisory Group: 2 November 2010: http://wp.me/p5foE-3er